Both are on Giftun, both cost about the same, and they are not the same day out.
Both landings are on Big Giftun, twenty minutes apart by boat, and both trips cost within a few euros of each other. The difference is what is under the water and how many people are on the sand.

Orange Bay is the postcard: a long white sandbar running into shallows so clear they barely register as sea, with a beach club, sunbeds and a bar behind it. The reef is a boat ride away rather than off the beach. It is also the busier of the two from about eleven until three.
Paradise Island has the better reef — the richest around the island, which is why boats stopping there carry divers as well as swimmers. The beach is smaller and plainer, the facilities fewer. If you came to look at coral, go here; if you came for the photograph and a sunlounger, go to Orange Bay.


Orange Bay is the postcard: a long white sandbar running into shallows so clear they barely register as sea, with a beach club, sunbeds and a bar behind it.
Both include two snorkel stops on the way, lunch on board and the inflatables in the afternoon. Neither is a bad day. Just book the one that matches what you actually want from it.

